| The A.T. Guide | The Thru-Hikers Handbook | ||
| Organization | BETTER | The A.T. Guide places relevant material on nearby pages; the THH's front/back format makes for a lot of page number look-ups. | |
| Profile Maps | WAY BETTER | The A.T. Guide's profile maps are roughly twice the size and much more detailed. All landmarks are aligned with the profile. | |
| Town Maps | WAY BETTER | The A.T. Guide's town maps are larger, proportionally scaled, and there are many more of them (50 instead of 28). | |
| Triple Shelter Mileages | UNMATCHED | The A.T. Guide shows cumulative distance to 3 shelters in each direction. | |
| GPS Coordinates | UNMATCHED | Enter GPS coordinates into your vehicle's GPS (or Google Earth) for help navigating to trailheads. | |
| Southbound Edition | UNMATCHED | Using this edition, southbound hikers can read north to south data normally, oriented front to back, top to bottom. | |
| Unbound Edition | UNMATCHED | Planing to cut out the sections you need? Save yourself the work & get a cleaner cut by purchasing pages that haven't been bound. | |
| Email Updates | UNMATCHED | Sign up to receive updates. | |
| Cost | CHEAPER | Cost with shipping from each book's website: A.T. Guide: $19.90, THH $22.50. Get a better book and pay $2.60 less! | |
| Name recognition | THH has been around many years and has changed little. Though some old-timers may truthfully advise that “it worked for them,” there is now an option that will work better for you. |